Today is the one-year anniversary of an event whose significance I still ponder: the arrival of the Amazon’s first response to a personal ad I placed as a cynical joke, with the idea that nobody would respond to it, but at least I’d have said exactly what I wanted to say about who I was, and what I was looking for. I broke every “rule” of personals writing; I said things that were negative, I was too honest, I listed some “must-haves” that seemed rigid and closed-minded; I didn’t post a picture, and I made it fairly clear that I didn’t want to see one in a response. The headline was: May I request that you be pleasantly neurotic?
I had been doing the online dating thing for about a year and a half; after breaking up with Mina, and after a great deal of self-reflection, I realized that my greatest liability in finding a compatible partner was my self-consciousness about saying “no, you’re not a good fit for me.” I had no dating experience at all in high school or college, and the women I’d become involved with in the past had been almost default-dates … we had been thrown together circumstantially, and I had an attitude that if a woman didn’t actively hate me, I should hang on to her. Oddly enough, I think some of them *did* actively hate me, but because I am a useful person to be around despite my vast catalog of deficiencies and annoyances, they all put up with me for far longer than one would ever imagine, given the continual complaints they had about me, and I about them. I wasn’t willing to continue doing that, and so I became very clear about what my dealbreakers were, and very clear with myself that I wouldn’t ever “settle” again. And yet I knew that I still had a tendency to think I didn’t deserve what I wanted, and that I needed practice in truly being myself with the opposite sex, and practice saying “Nice to meet you, but we’re a mismatch.”
I went on a lot of dates and said no. Two women made it to three dates before I said no, but I said no to all of them. On several occasions, after the first date things just trickled off into nowhereland, because we both could tell things weren’t working; but a lot of the time, I had to say no. And it wasn’t easy. I think it is better to be honest than to give some vague reason why “things just won’t work out” — but I got some arguments, and some insults thrown back at me. A common one was my being told I was “too uptight” for not wanting to date women who were actively abusing alcohol and regularly smoking weed. And I was “too judgmental” for choosing not to date women who clearly put their sex/love life ahead of the emotional welfare of their children (my attitude has always been that you have your whole life to get laid, and one chance to raise your kids). I was “unrealistic” for not wanting to date women who were clearly on the rebound, or hung up on some guy in their work or friend circles who wouldn’t ask them out. And of course there was always the “Geez, can’t you just give me a chance?” To which my reply was, inevitably: “Aren’t you embarrassed to be asking me that question? Why would you want to date someone who wasn’t excited to be dating you?”
I learned from these experiences that I can discern more about someone from a handful of pixels on a screen than anyone would ever believe. I could tell which ones I’d like, but who wouldn’t be a good fit. I could tell which ones would be an exercise in an awkward hour in Hell. I could tell which ones would be great conversationalists but who were essentially irresponsible grownup kids. After a while I simply became fascinated by the accuracy of my radar, despite the fact that these dates were a complete waste of my time. I kept thinking, “Oh surely you’ll be wrong this time.” But I never was.
And so when the Amazon’s email arrived, I puzzled over it. The radar approved, despite the fact that the writer’s laconic and understated style didn’t give away much about her. But what I did know about her, instinctively, was that she was worth meeting in person; some people just aren’t text-oriented, and that’s fine. A couple of brief exchanges established a mutual certainty that we should at least meet for coffee, and then a combination of a snowstorm and the holidays prevented that happening until after the first of the year.
I remember very clearly that I almost didn’t respond back to her email. My hesitation was not due to any negative feeling about it; rather, I was afraid that my radar was right about her, but that she wouldn’t like me. I was good at saying “no,” but not so good, perhaps, at being told “no.” And I still wonder what was happening on her end of the screen; as far as I know, she was not someone who responded to personals ads, though as many people do, she read them for the entertainment value (we met on Craigslist, the lunatic clearinghouse of the world). What curious little trick of timing caused me to post that particular ad, and her to see it? And what prompted her to do something uncharacteristic, and respond to it? I know she had recently returned from a very enjoyable bike racing vacation, which was something she hadn’t been able to enjoy while she was married, so maybe she was just in a “what the hell, it’s my life again now” kind of mood. She’d recently had a birthday, so perhaps there was also some feeling of “what the hell, time is passing, I might as well try this.”
If I were a different person, I would attribute all of this to some kind of Larger Intervention or Fate. This tiny event aligned with that tiny event, and so we met, and the delicate balance of the Universe assisted us. But you know — what I really think is that Fate doesn’t have a “one chance, and you’re done” policy. Perhaps the Amazon and I had barely missed each other on a number of prior occasions, but we will never know that. By a truly bizarre coincidence, ten years ago I dated someone else who worked at the same small custom bike shop where she was working at the time. My point is that if she hadn’t responded to my ad, or I hadn’t responded to her email, it wouldn’t have made any difference in the long run. I think we are, in fact, destined to be together, and destiny isn’t so easily discouraged. But I’m glad she did see my ad, and I’m glad I responded to her — because destiny and time are two different things, and I do hate to waste time.